Living with a health system devastated by decades of conflict, many Afghans are unable to access essential healthcare services.

Barriers including costs and distance mean that ordinary Afghans are struggling to access emergency, critical and maternal care—key components of a functioning health system, according to new research from EMERGENCY, which has been operating in Afghanistan since 1999, and CRIMEDIM.

Through surveys and interviews with more than 1,600 patients, caregivers and healthcare workers across 11 provinces, “Access to Emergency, Critical, and Operative Care in Afghanistan” centres Afghans’ first-hand experiences in order to understand the barriers to healthcare in the country.

AFGHANISTAN’S EVOLVING DISEASE BURDEN: THE IMPORTANCE OF ECO CARE

In Afghanistan, the prevalence of noncommunicable diseases is increasing, rates of trauma-related injuries remain high, and women consistently face some of the worst maternal health risks in the world.

Yet despite the clear and expanding need, Afghanistan’s emergency, critical and operative care services are largely insufficient after decades of violence and underinvestment, from infrastructure and workforce inadequacies to the heavy burdens placed on those seeking care.

Covering a wide range of important and life-saving care, emergency, critical and operative services encompass trauma and obstetric emergencies, intensive care, life support systems and surgical operations.

These are vital in achieving Universal Health Coverage and enhancing health system resilience. Limited access often results in preventable deaths.

INSIDE THE REPORT: ACCESS TO EMERGENCY, CRITICAL, AND OPERATIVE CARE IN AFGHANISTAN

After decades of resources directed toward military and defence, Afghanistan’s healthcare infrastructure is unable to meet the growing needs of the population.

Physical barriers prove one of the most difficult for patients to overcome: just over 2% were able to use a public ambulance to access health services. Nearly half—many of whom live in Afghanistan’s mountainous rural areas—had to travel on foot.

Once facilities have been reached, they often struggle to provide the appropriate care. As medical providers, the staff at public hospitals offered a unique perspective on the overlapping barriers to care, from infrastructure to finances to cultural expectations:

“Sometimes the power goes out in the middle of surgery. We use phone flashlights or wait until the generator starts. It’s dangerous for the patient.”

Doctor, provincial hospital in Helmand

“There are communities or households according to my experience that can’t even afford the money for the fuel or to get a car and to reach the hospital, how can they do [so] during an emergency?”

Chief Surgeon, public hospital in Kabul

“We have a lot of emergencies, but often there’s no female doctor available, especially at night. Families sometimes prefer to wait until morning rather than let their daughters be seen by a male doctor.”

Chief Gynaecologist, provincial hospital in Laghman

“At the comprehensive health centre level and district hospital level, we have an ambulance system [...]. But in very remote areas we have no system."

Hospital Director, Paktia

"We need trainings, in general surgery, trauma, trauma life support, at all levels of the health system.”

Chief Surgeon, provincial hospital in Laghman

As a consequence of the widespread historic neglect of the public healthcare system, the vast majority of respondents were forced to travel to another city, province or even another country to access the services they need, including 76% of those seeking maternal care.

Women in particular were more likely to be scared when accessing care, and faced additional delays due to restrictive gender norms. Women may not disclose health conditions until they are severe, while expectations of being treated by female health practitioners limit treatment options.

Facing this widespread series of overlapping obstacles, one in four patients were forced to postpone a surgical operation at least once, the report finds, while one in five has missed a follow-up appointment. Delaying essential care frequently leads to worse health outcomes, in turn putting an even greater strain on the health system: over 33% of those surveyed reported a disability or death due to delayed care.

Based on the input of more than 1,600 Afghan participants, the report concludes with 10 recommendations.

 

Over 1,600 Afghan patients, caregivers and medical staff involved

Access to Emergency, Critical, and Operative Care in Afghanistan

THE RESEARCH TEAM

EMERGENCY has been committed to providing and improving care in Afghanistan since 1999. Today, EMERGENCY operates two Surgical Centres in Kabul and Lashkar-Gah; a Surgical and Paediatric Centre in Anabah; a Maternity Centre in Anabah; and a network of over 40 First Aid Posts and Primary Healthcare Centres connected by a 24/7 ambulance service.

CRIMEDIM is the Center for Research and Training in Disaster Medicine, Humanitarian Aid and Global Health at the Università del Piemonte Orientale. CRIMEDIM’s projects revolve around health system resilience strengthening, access to care as well as community preparedness and response to emergencies and disasters, both in high-income countries and fragile and conflict-affected settings.

EMERGENCY and CRIMEDIM previously collaborated on the 2023 report, Access to Care in Afghanistan, which can be seen here.